When Gumball and Darwin made it back home, Nicole was outside on the front porch. All the pages were missing, but Gumball said that he wasn't going back in there.
They finally made it out of there alive, and Tobias said that he was really sorry for all this. But then Gumball saw the exit, so Darwin tried to keep on running.
Darwin said that he couldn't run anymore. While they were running, Gumball yelled out, "I'M GONNA KILL FOR THIS, TOBIAS!" When Darwin said, "I THINK THE SLENDERMAN'S GONNA TAKE CARE OF THAT FOR US!" They all kept on running from the Slenderman, who keep telling them to give back the pages, trying to keep thier lives. Tobias yelled out, "ITS THE SLENDERMAN! HE'S REAL!" So they all started to run for thier lives. When they turned around to see who it was, they saw only a figure in a black suit, with no face, and had tenticales. Then they heard someone walking behind them. Something was starting to freak them out. But then Tobias said that he heard the same thing. Gumball said it was probably just a squirrel. On the way home, Darwin said that he heard something in the bushes. Gumball and Darwin were kinda mad at him, but in the end, they all had a great laugh, and Tobias said that he was sorry for scarring them, so they all headed home. He said that he planned the whole thing all along. They were really scared, but it was only Tobias. When all of a sudden, someone came up and spooked them really hard And Scorpion Said Sub-Zero Will See This. As they continued thier search, they kept on finding pages that said stuff like, "Leave Me Alone", and "Watch where you step".Gumball remembered that Tobias said that there was eight pages, and they already found seven, and there was still no sign of the Slenderman. Gumball thinks a joke that Tobias placed here, so they continued on into the forest. As they come up to a tree, there is a piece of paper that says, "Don't Look Back". Since it was dark, Gumball brought his flashlight to see. Then when they arrive at the entrance of the dark forrest, there is a sign there that says "DO NOT ENTER! SLENDER INSIDE!" Darwin says that he is scared and doesn't want to go in, but he keep his promise and came along with him. Darwin comes with him, because he doesn't want Gumball to go in there alone. Latter that night, Gumball made a dummy of himself and put it in his bed. Gumball didn't want to, but he didn't wanted to be called a "coward" anymore, so accepts Tobias's dare. But then he dares Gumball to go into the dark forest at night, and bring back the eight pages. Gumball says to the other kids that all that stuff Tobias said is fake. He also says that there are eight pages of him there too, in other ways they are clues to being rich, but nobody knows. He says that he comes out at night and only appears in the dark forest, so he can scare people. He says that there is something called the "Slenderman". Latter in the hallways, Tobias is telling a scary story tale to the other kids. Gumball tells to Darwin that he is not feeling any "thrill" in his life, so he trys to find something scary to do.
The episode starts out with the kids on the bus on the way to school. Tobias dares Gumball and Darwin to go into the dark forest at night to find the eight pages of the Slenderman.